2012/02/22

401(k) to IRA Rollovers – What are your dos and don’ts

401(k) and IRA Rollover considerations

Individuals considering 401(k) Rollovers to an IRA often make expensive mistakes.  These mistakes range from the simple to the complex.  A simple mistake occurs when an employee takes a check when they retire and their employer must withhold 20%.  In order to complete the tax-free rollover, the IRA owner needs to replace the 20% withheld by their employer using their own funds to meet the tax-free rollover requirement within 60 days.  A more complex mistake occurs if the advisor does not realize that his client was born prior to January 1st, 1936 and is qualified for 10-year averaging.  There could be a significant difference in tax liability if a normal rollover is completed.  For a more comprehensive examination of options and restrictions, please click HERE

 

What are some major ‘dos and don’ts’ when considering 401(k) to IRA Rollovers?

Do:  Consider the immediate need for the money.

If immediate distributions are required before 59 ½ and there’s been a separation of service from the company, then leaving the money in the 401(k) may be more advantageous.  If a IRA rollover has already occurred before age 59 ½ then and a distribution is required, then using Rule 72t may help avoid penalties.

 

Do:  Make optimal use of creditor protection.

Some IRA owners and financial advisors think that recent changes to federal bankruptcy rules automatically protect IRAs.  That’s not necessarily true.  For creditor protection purposes, it’s best to leave funds in a qualified plan because ERISA gives complete creditor protection to qualified plans.  NOTE- One person qualified plans do not receive the same protection – there needs to be at least one ‘real’ employee in the plan.  Be aware that when you roll assets from a company plan to an IRA, you may lose creditor protection, so it is wise to check with legal counsel.

 

Do:  Re-check your beneficiaries

According to ERISA, a company retirement plan (qualified plan) states that you must name your spouse as a beneficiary or get spousal consent to name another person.  The same rules do not apply to IRAs.  In creating a IRA rollover account, you have the flexibility to name the beneficiaries you desire.

 

Don’t:  Get a check from the company

The company must withhold 20% from the payment, so that a person with a $100,000 account will have $20,000 withheld and will receive a check for $80,000.  To complete a tax-free rollover, the tax-payer must deposit the $80,000 in the IRA plus $20,000 from their pocket to make up for the money withheld by the company to complete the $100,000 rollover.  The sensible way to move funds is a direct custodian to custodian transfer of the funds.

 

Don’t:  Rollover company stock

Ignore this guideline only if the amount of employer stock is small or the basis of the shares is high relative to the current market value of the stock.  Generally, in the case of large amounts of shares or low basis, it would be a costly mistake not to use the Net Unrealized Appreciation (NUA) rules outlined in IRA Publication 575, 2007

 

Don’t:  Rollover after-tax dollars

If possible at the time of rollover, it may be preferable to remove after tax dollars and not roll them to an IRA.  The question is, “will you need the money soon?”  If so, it probably won’t pay to rollover the after-tax money to an IRA because one you roll over after-tax money to an IRA you cannot withdraw it tax-free.

 

For a more comprehensive examination of these guidelines, click HERE

For How to Use a Self Directed IRA to Diversify, click HERE

For the Characteristics of an Ideal Investment, which might suite your objectives in a Self Directed IRA, click HERE

For assistance, information or discussing your options for rolling a 401(k) into an IRA, either after leaving an employer or while still in service, contact Scott Scholz, Independent Financial Consultant.  Call 425-829-4110 or email scott@scottscholz.com

Use a Self-Directed IRA to Diversify

As people experience the current state of the economy with the sub-prime mortgage debacle, near collapses by banking and insurance giants, as well as a plummeting stock market and shrinking retirement accounts, they want to take back control of their investments.

Many are also disenchanted with the traditional investments available through typical retirement plans like an IRA or their company’s 401(K) plan.  The range of investment options via an employer’s retirement plan is generally restricted to a limited number of mutual funds and/or company stock.

These funds do not provide protection of principal against downward market risks, which can be found among numerous prudent alternatives available today.  Furthermore, mutual funds provide limited opportunity for true diversification beyond stocks or bonds.

Additionally, a Harvard University study in 2006 proved that performance of mutual funds managed by investors working on their own is 6.626% and funds provided by financial advisors averaged 2.924%, net of all expenses (Morningstar.com and Harvard Business School website), bringing advisor recommendations under question.

More and more investors are moving away from mutual fund managers and the volatile stock market and making their own decisions using Self-Directed IRAs to invest in traditional and non-traditional assets.

An investment portfolio constructed of uncorrelated assets can achieve an overall stronger rate of return with a lower level of risk, mitigate the volatility of the equity markets and conquer the eroding impact of inflation on purchasing power and long term investment performance.  There is a mountain of statistical evidence and Nobel Prize winning research that supports this approach.  However, it’s extremely difficult to achieve these results if you invest mainly in one asset class, for example, stocks via the mutual funds offered in an employer’s 401(K).

So what can you do with a Self Directed IRA?

“Everyday Americans are fed up with the failures of so-called financial wizards,” Provident Group Board noted. “People want to be accountable for and control their own investment destinies. With self-directed retirement accounts they can do just that.”

It is a little known fact that Self-Directed IRAs have been available since the creation of traditional IRAs by the Employee Retirement Income Act of 1974.  Also, typical traditional and Roth IRAs allow for $5000 to $6000 annual contributions.  However, Self-Directed IRAs and Solo 401(K) and Solo 401(K) Roth programs allow for contributions up to $49,000 annually, depending upon age.

In the past, over 97% of retirement accounts have been dictated by the traditional investments available in the market.  This has been largely controlled by fear of the unknown.  Traditional custodians and brokers have falsely claimed that self-directed IRAs are complicated, risky and illegal.  Due to economic concerns gripping America today, people are educating themselves, taking back control and are no longer depending on traditional methods to invest in IRAs.

Investment News (Sept 2007) reported a projection of a 10-12% increase in IRA rollovers from 2007-2010.  The trend will likely increase with the collapse of the traditional markets in 2008 and 2009 and as investors look to other means to recover losses and achieve greater financial success and security.

Many people are turning their attention to the variety of investment options available within the self-directed IRA including:

  • Residential and Commercial Real Estate
  • Life Settlements
  • TICs (Tenants in Common)
  • Tax Liens, Tax Deeds
  • Mortgages, Loans, Notes
  • Real Estate Options
  • Small Businesses, Franchises
  • Private and Publicly Listed Stock
  • Limited Liability Companies
  • Limited Partnerships

IRA investment regulations are largely regulated by what you can’t do with them rather than what you can.  This is what makes self-directed IRAs of non-traditional investments possible.  There are very few prohibited transactions:

  • life insurance for yourself
  • collectibles
  • metal, gems, and stamps
  • rugs and antiques
  • coins
  • artwork
  • alcoholic beverages
  • Sub Chapter S Corporations.

Setting up a self-directed IRA:

The IRS requires a custodian to administer the retirement funds.  After the funds are moved to a non-traditional custodian, you direct your funds to the investment of your choosing.  The custodian will facilitate the investment purchase as required by IRS code.  If setting up legal services, such as an LLC is necessary, they can also assist with that.  Once investments are made the custodian will administer the account and hold the investment documents for safe-keeping.  Any profit or income from the investment goes directly back to your IRA account.

Two categories to consider for a Self-Directed IRA:

Life Settlements

A life settlement is simply the sale, or transfer of ownership, of an existing life insurance policy to another party. Typically, the individual selling the policy no longer wants or needs or can afford it, and desires to sell it to a third party via a secondary market.

Historically, larger institutions have been the primary purchasers of these policies.  Now, fractions of policies may be purchased by accredited retail purchasers. These investors purchase the policy at a discount to its face value, keeping the policy in force until maturity. Upon maturity, the investors receive the full face value of the policy as their return on investment. These funds return to your self-directed IRA and grow tax-deferred in a traditional IRA or tax-free if using a Roth IRA.

The typical policy is purchased from someone over 78 years of age with a definable life expectancy. The owner has decided that the policy is either no longer affordable or necessary, and thus chooses to sell the policy rather than let it lapse, thereby converting the death benefit into a life benefit for their use. These special use policies might be for Estate Planning, Key-Man or Large-Loan policies. Typically, these policies are $1 million – $20 million in face value.

Life settlements provide contractual guarantee of principal and are completely uncorrelated to any other markets.  The return on investment is not impacted by the equity, bond or commodity markets, interest rates, oil prices or other economic events.  A life settlements investment represents true diversification, principal protection and has delivered a strong double digit rate of return each and every year for over 18 years.

Real Estate

The first thing to remember when your IRA purchases real estate is that the property is for investment purposes only. Your IRA must take title to the property. For example: Custodian Name FBO (for the benefit of) John Smith IRA. Your IRA may purchase property from an unrelated party (anyone who is not disqualified). Any income from the property such as rent goes back into the IRA. Likewise, any expenses, such as property management fees, maintenance etc., are paid from your IRA. It is advisable to use a property management company to avoid any prohibited transactions. When the property is sold, funds also go back into the IRA and remain tax-deferred or tax-free if using a Roth IRA.

There are various ways to purchase real estate. You may form an LLC and pool different funds together to purchase. For instance, you may use your IRA funds together with personal funds, a non-recourse loan, or with other investors. These different entities all own a part of the LLC, percentages being based on the amount of money invested.

Below are just some of the types of real estate you can invest in with your IRA:

  • Residential homes, condominiums, duplexes, four-plexes
  • Commercial retail, apartment complexes, office condominiums, homes
  • Industrial manufacturing, warehouses
  • Land

A non-recourse loan may also be secured to purchase investment real estate with your IRA. Typically the down payment for these loans is 30% to 40%. Guidelines for these loans do not normally use credit scores or income for loan qualifications.  These loans enable diversification across several properties within an IRA.

Truly Self Directed IRAs:

Where you open your IRA usually determines your available investment options.  You may be comfortable with your bank or financial institution, but your investment opportunities may be limited by their own self-interest.  A truly self-directed IRA custodian acts as a passive partner in your transactions.  They will be able to answer any administrative and legal questions pertaining to your IRA, but the power is in your hands when it comes to investment options and decisions.

Many major employers allow employees to re-position funds they’ve placed in their company’s qualified plans into a self-directed IRA that they can manage themselves.  You should observe the prescribed process pertaining to the chosen investment to preserve the tax advantages and avoid any penalties.  The process is not complicated and can produce net benefits that make the exercise worthwhile.  This enables the individual to have access to a wider range of investment options than may be available via an employer’s qualified plan.  Investors can achieve greater safety and performance of his entire investment portfolio with a prudently executed and managed strategy.