Debtor vs. Saver vs. Wealth Creator & the Private Reserve System.
What is the best way to make those major capital purchases that occur during your lifetime, such as automobiles, major appliances, weddings, education or even homes?
Most people believe the same thing I was told when I was young: Save money until you have enough and you can afford to buy what you want. Don’t spend money you don’t have. Don’t borrow money. Don’t pay interest.
The only accepted exception to this would be using a mortgage to purchase a home. But conventional wisdom states you should pay off that mortgage as fast as possible. Does that match what you believe to be the right or the most efficient way to use your money?
The fact is you finance everything you buy. Either you pay interest when you borrow, or you give up interest you could have earned when you pay cash. You must consider the costs associated with these purchases, especially the Opportunity Costs. It’s not just what you pay… it’s ‘How’ you pay for it.
Let’s assume you want to buy a new car and the one you want costs $30,000. If you live according to the teaching above, you work hard to save up enough money so you can buy the car. How many cars will you buy over your lifetime? Your auto acquisition process through life might look like this picture of the Saver’s Cycle in Figure 1:
Figure 1. Saver’s Cycle.
You save enough, purchase the car and deplete the savings and start saving again for the next purchase.
On the other hand, some people find themselves in need of a new vehicle but they don’t have the money saved for the purchase. They must borrow the money and then work to pay it off. They might fall into an acquisition process like the Debtor’s Cycle, see Figure 2.
Figure 2. Debtor’s Cycle.
The Debtor borrows the money and works to get back to zero. Interestingly, the Saver ends up in the same place. The Saver saves and then spends his way back to zero. Check Figures 1 and 2 again and note the Zero line. Indeed, The Debtor loses money that he pays in interest to the lender. That’s a primary reason for the widespread conventional wisdom to avoid borrowing. But, if you make the $30,000 cash purchase, you also lose money. In fact, you potentially lose even more money than The Debtor. Let’s look closely at the costs and then look at a third way to make these types of purchases.
Let’s say you’re ‘The Saver,’ you already have $30,000 and you’re ready to buy your car. (By the way, it works just as well for $10,000 cars or $80,000 cars.) The question: “Is the smartest way to buy the car to a) pay $30,000 cash for the car or to b) keep control of the cash in a safe place earning a rate of return and borrow $30,000 from the dealer and pay interest on a loan?”
Assume the terms for borrowing from the dealer are 6% and the $30,000 is amortized over 5 years. You’d pay $580 per month for the car, a total of $4799 interest over the 5 years and have the car loan paid off. See the upper half of Figure 3.
Let’s also say you took the $30,000 cash you were going to use to pay for the car and instead put it in a safe place and earned 6% (the same as the cost of the loan) over the next 5 years.
What would your $30,000 become in five years compounding at 6%? Your $30,000 would earn $10,466 in interest and grow to $40,466 by the time you have the car paid off. See the lower half of Figure 3.
Figure 3. Amortizing at 6%, Compounding at 6%.
By NOT paying $30,000 cash for the car, you allowed your money to earn $10,466 in 5 years. Meanwhile, you paid $4799 in interest over those 5 years, netting $5,667. If you borrow rather than pay cash, you’re actually $5,667 financially better off after 5 years!
| Interest earned @ 6% |
$10,466 |
| Interest paid @ 6% |
-$4,799 |
| Net gain by borrowing vs paying cash |
$5,667 |
Another perspective is that by paying cash, your Lost Opportunity Cost on your money is $5,667 and you actually would lose more money by paying cash for the car than by borrowing and simply paying the $4,799 in interest.
What if the loan only cost 4% and you earned 7%? Reason tells you The Lost Opportunity Cost would be even greater, doesn’t it? You’re right:
| Interest earned @ 7% |
$12,077 |
| Interest paid @ 4% |
-$3,150 |
| Net gain by borrowing vs paying cash |
$8,927 |
Let’s revisit the question, ”How many cars will you buy during your lifetime and what would paying cash actually cost you in lost opportunity costs over your lifetime?” Imagine this cycle recurring 5 times if you bought 5 cars over your lifetime. That’s almost a $44,500 unnecessary “Wealth Transfer” to lost opportunity costs that’s due to ‘How’ you pay for your car (if you pay 4% and earn 7%, as in the example above.) Is paying cash the most efficient use of your money?
There’s a more efficient way. Rather than being a Debtor or a Saver, what if you try the “Wealth Creator’s Cycle?“ In this case, rather than save and then spend your money on the car and lose control of your cash, you accumulate and collateralize your money and retain control of your cash. You allow your money to continue to compound, build greater wealth, increasing your collateral capacity. See Figure 4.
Figure 4. Wealth Creator’s Cycle.
You might begin your own Private Reserve Account once you save some amount of money – $5000 or $10,000, in our example, $30,000, that you collateralize and repay repeatedly. You never allow your money to be ‘consumed’ by the purchase of the car. That enables the $30,000 to continue compounding for you throughout your life, increasing your collateral capacity and putting you in a stronger financial position in the future.
Which is the most efficient way to optimize the performance of your money for you as you make major capital purchase – including your home? Debtor? Saver? Or Wealth Creator?
If you’re in wealth-building mode and want to optimize the performance of cash flow and assets, the answer should be clear. Math is emotion-less and it doesn’t lie. The difference over 10 year or 30 years can be incredibly life changing. See Figure 4.
Building your own ‘Private Reserve Account’ and using the ‘Wealth Creator Cycle’ for capital purchases and other projects during your lifetime will help avoid unnecessary ‘wealth transfers’ due to lost opportunity costs and place you in a much stronger financial position. You can apply the same strategy to areas other than capital purchases, as well, e.g., paying for children’s/grandchildren’s college expenses, starting a business, investment capital, paying for your home, etc.
If you’d like to learn how to increase your collateral capacity, build a Private Reserve account and how you can make it work for your projects, call for a no obligation consultation. But don’t delay. As we discussed last time, the one thing you can never recapture is time.
To Your Prosperity,
Scott, January 2012
Scott Scholz
Independent Registered Financial Consultant
425-829-4110 www.ScottScholz.com scott@scottscholz.com
PS Financial success is achieved by following the right principles, not following the current ‘right predictions’ which change from day to day. “The Fiscal Fitness Letter” presents the ‘Right Principles’ for financial success and challenges misleading conventional paradigms about money and achieving financial independence. If the principles presented here make sense to you, please share them with those you care about. Add their name to The Fiscal Fitness Letter mailing list above.
“Your mind is like a parachute. It’s only functional when open.” – Tolleson









